To Save Everything, Click Here: The Folly of Technological Solutionism

By Evgeny Morozov

In the very close to destiny, “smart” applied sciences and “big facts” will let us make large-scale and complex interventions in politics, tradition, and lifestyle. expertise will let us clear up difficulties in hugely unique methods and create new incentives to get extra humans to do the suitable factor. yet how will such “solutionism” impact our society, as soon as deeply political, ethical, and irresolvable dilemmas are recast as uncontroversial and simply practicable issues of technological potency? What if a few such difficulties are easily vices in cover? What if a few friction in communique is efficient and a few hypocrisy in politics worthy? The temptation of the electronic age is to mend everything—from crime to corruption to toxins to obesity—by digitally quantifying, monitoring, or gamifying habit. but if we modify the motivations for our ethical, moral, and civic habit we can also swap the very nature of that habit. expertise, Evgeny Morozov proposes, could be a strength for improvement—but provided that we maintain solutionism in fee and learn how to relish the imperfections of liberal democracy. a few of these imperfections are usually not unintentional yet via design.

Arguing that we badly desire a new, post-Internet approach to debate the ethical outcomes of electronic applied sciences, To shop every little thing, click on Here warns opposed to an international of seamless potency, the place everyone seems to be compelled to put on Silicon Valley’s electronic straitjacket.

Show description

Quick preview of To Save Everything, Click Here: The Folly of Technological Solutionism PDF

Show sample text content

Politics, during this version, is imagined as which include little else yet solving potholes and working with stray canine. Political concerns are decreased to administrative matters—and these should be settled scientifically, so there isn't any have to waste time discussing their advantages and perpetuating all of the messiness of the political strategy. therefore, Jeff Jarvis 132 9781610391382-text_morozov 12/13/12 4:10 PM web page 133 tips on how to holiday Politics via solving It tells us that “if the geeks take over—and they will—we might input an period of medical rationality in govt.

Whilst larger teach maps earn you issues on human rights and secrecy indexes, whatever has to be profoundly improper with our scoring process. Even democracies can't withstand such temptations. simply examine the US: less than Obama’s direction—nominally the period of “more open and obvious government”—his management aggressively prosecuted leakers and whistle-blowers, elevated the government’s type application, or even forbade newshounds from disclosing the names of federal staff championing its opengovernment paintings!

Either actual and digital environments—walls, pavements, doorways, log-in screens—have develop into “smart. ” that's, they've got built-in the plethora of information generated by way of the selftracking units and social-networking prone in order that now they could are expecting and forestall legal habit just by studying their clients. And as clients don’t also have the opportunity to dedicate crimes, prisons are not any longer wanted both. A triumph of humanism, courtesy of Silicon Valley. xi 9781610391382-text_morozov 12/13/12 4:10 PM web page xii advent after which, there’s the flourishing new “marketplace” of “ideas.

Today’s straitjacket may be of the electronic sort, yet it’s not often the 1st or the tightest. whereas the note “solutionism” won't were used, many vital thinkers have addressed its shortcomings, whether utilizing diverse phrases and contexts. I’m pondering, specifically, of Ivan Illich’s protestations opposed to the hugely effective yet dehumanizing platforms education and drugs, Jane Jacobs’s assaults at the vanity of city planners, Michael Oakeshott’s uprising opposed to rationalists in all walks of human life, Hans Jonas’s impatience with the chilly convenience of cybernetics; and, extra lately, James Scott’s trouble with how states have compelled what he calls “legibility” on their topics.

Apparently, Lessig’s aspect here's the complete opposite of what he wrote within the New Republic in regards to the community “not going away,” yet this is often infrequently miraculous: Lessig’s educational self is aware that there’s not anything fastened approximately “the Internet,” yet his activist self additionally is aware that claiming that it’s right here to stick will make his advocacy a lot easier). this can be what submit really writes: There are legislation of Nature. . . . There are legislation of progress, and scale, and association, the explanation why site visits, web connectivity, the inhabitants of towns, and the frequency of phrases all persist with an identical development, the explanation why the single worldwide community is the single with end-to-end layout and allotted routing, even though we most likely comprehend these legislation .

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.64 of 5 – based on 39 votes